'professionals' register

Hi,

I'm just wondering if there already exists a sort of consolidated sticky thread about "professionals" that others here have dealt with, and their locations, solicitors, conveyencers, mortgage brokers, REAs, PMs, etc.

It just strikes me as somewhat of a valid idea to create such a thread so that someone is able to go "well, i need a solicitor in bonnydoon cause i haven't done X in that location before... who else have somersoftians dealt with and liked ?"

something long the lines of:
role: Accountant
loc: Vic
Comments: helped me rearrange all my book keeping, charges appropriate fees and friendly to deal with. can be dealt with remotely, etc

any thoughts ?
 
We'd need to be careful about potential liability issues - firstly from people thinking that these are recommendations or endorsements (even if they clearly aren't), and secondly from potentially libellous comments that people may make.

Not saying it can't be done - just saying it's not as easy as it seems :(
 
As a mortgage broker who has sourced clients from this forum, I appreciate the merit for a register of this type, but I'd really prefer it wasn't done.

I'd prefer people read posts in the areas they're interested in, or ask for current recommendations. A register like this would require continuous management to weed out those who might register and never contribute.
 
We'd need to be careful about potential liability issues - firstly from people thinking that these are recommendations or endorsements (even if they clearly aren't), and secondly from potentially libellous comments that people may make.

Not saying it can't be done - just saying it's not as easy as it seems :(

sim - I did have that thought in the back of my mind.. that there might nede to be some very vigilant and heavy handed moderation...
as well as the disclaimer stuff..

and PTBear - i don't mean for the professionals themselves to register, but for instance, if you worked with a good PM in, say, bourke, then you could say that you had a good experience with the PM etc..

but then i suppose we get the people promoting themselves..
 
I'll back Peter on this one...

as one of the "professionals" (hehehe - yeah right!!!:p) I also can see some merit in the idea, but given that things change so often, who/how will it be kept current.

It is simple to ask a question in the general forum for a recommendation at the time...I have been fortunate enough to be recommended in this regard (thanks to those who past my name on:)) and am always willing to share the names of folks who I have dealt with that have done a good job when i've dealt with them - whether privately as an investor, or professionally as an REA.

my 2c...

cheers
UC:D
 
We'd need to be careful about potential liability issues - firstly from people thinking that these are recommendations or endorsements (even if they clearly aren't), and secondly from potentially libellous comments that people may make.

Not saying it can't be done - just saying it's not as easy as it seems :(



Sim -

There used to be a sort of 'Who Does It' facility accessible from the Home Page at one time / in one version. Not many people actually listed themselves in it - the last time I checked for it was about three years ago.


When I had the child care centre I set aside a section of the main notice board for parents to post up their business cards. You know, warm & fuzzy, community action board, that type of thing.

Mike and I used one of the parents' services - he was a bricklayer - to build a garage. Yep, that was a great idea! Never heard of a spirit level, perhaps the only spirits were those he ingested. Then he charged us eight hours for watching the concrete floor set, then he barged around demanding payment. All in all, after that I took down all the business cards, put up a few posters in the blank spaces and adopted a low profile with regards to who did what.



Camel, good service, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. Good service also cuts both ways - you may be a great customer for your bookkeeper - always have everything ready, find them easy to deal with, they have built up a good relationship with you, you think they're terrific.

Someone else goes to the bookkeeper you like so much and doesn't like them at all. That someone else is totally disorganised and isn't wanting a bookkeeper, they are wanting a Mother. Your bookkeeper isn't into Mothering so the two do not have common expectations of the encounter.

You get my drift.

Professionally, I come across a lot of people who 'do things'. However, unless I have personally experienced their level of service I can not possibly say 'Joe Blow is a great building inspector' unless I have engaged Joe Blow myself. I can, of course, say 'Joe Blow is a building inspector and is apparently experienced in Nissan huts, you may care to get a quote from him for your next job', and that is hardly a recommendation.


Personally, I think we can be far too quick to 'recommend' someone to do something. A recommendation actually joins us in the action. I make it very clear to my customers that I can recommend no-one, and if they are looking for a conveyancer or building inspector or whatever they may care to include Joe Blow in their ring around, and this is why they may care to include them. Further than that could be taken as urging and as my customers are adults it would be inappropriate for me to urge them to do anything.


So while a directory listing may sound like a good idea in theory, in practise it can be fraught with problems. It is often best for people to find their own Nissan hut inspector.

Cheers

Kristine
 
Suggestion re professional referrals

I hear all the dangers of having a "register" as such, and I understand.

However, Sim, may I suggest that you create a folder within the forum structure called "Requests for professionals by location" or something (why can't I think of good wording right now?), so that these requests can be all gathered together, instead of mixed in with all the other posts?
 
Back
Top