Not should, but could. If someone is in a position to do someone else a favour and can afford it, then it would certainly be greatly appreciated. As I said before, if in their position i'd have no hesitation to help someone out.
You cannot make someone do what you might do, in any situation. Perhaps their financial situation means they don't want to borrow (or use their own cash) to buy you out at a "market price" when obviously the place is not saleable right now at what you and/or they consider to be "market price". Perhaps it is not worth what any of you think, at this time.
In the meantime, it is bringing in rent, none of you have a debt on it, so time might just do you a favour, and when the market improves, you can sell it for more than you are happy to accept now.
And as an ongoing concern, less owners is less hassle.
They're not taking on debt so I don't get your point.
Wouldn't they have to borrow to buy you out. Or at least use cash, which they might have other plans for. Without knowing any more, this would seem to be the case.
I'm not painting my whole life as doom and gloom. Far from it. I'm very much grateful for the inheritance but also stating that the little bit of rent I get each year doesn't change my life. Selling the place would.
Are you happy to tell us what the place is worth, and how much rent is coming in. Are we talking a lot of money or a little? And what difference it would make to you, especially if you could actually buy now (as your post seems to say).
Your comment that "there's no such thing as a little debt" is interesting. Are you wanting to buy outright and have no debt? Having debt is what has made us financially comfortable. Debt doesn't bother me at all, but I much prefer debt that is building our portfolio.
Really trying to help here, as I think you might need to look at things differently.