Yeah cheers Dazz.
I know nothing will give us a step by step, just trying to understanad where the convo you / Rixter brought up aobut LOE/difficulties of LOE might have led to etc a bit better since it seemed the 2 views were a qutie a bit different.
Sometimes I talk too much. Perhaps if I'd let the conversaton keep going instead of trying to clarify the question, which as you point out, may not be the right one in the first place... Or perhaps I'm too curious for curiosity's sake - I don't even know if my attempts will fall over like a house of cards after an unexpected wind of unexpected issues.. anwyway.....
Your description of Chris' capitally growing retirment example reminded me in some way of Jan Somers' book etc. That wasn't early retirement either... I don't think it was exhorbitant either.
When I do numbers myself, starting where I am & sayng "what if I did nothing else for 10 yrs, how woudl it look then ?" (of course, I assume growth /rent/expenses will rise by what I calculate which may not be accurate at all but hey, what do you do right ?).. then I've said "what if I bought this & later did that"
At the end of the day, I come up with various scenarios, but one thing they all have in common is (sides the assumptions I made which I already talked about), is it seems that they hinge on decisions / rules which I have no control over.