The environment and lifestyle in Meadowbank area is excellent. I was living there for 6 months few years back, really like the quiet and relaxable life style. I love to go cycling or jogging in the morning on weekend around the wharf and bush. Transport to city is great, shopping in Top Ryde is only 5 mins drive, grocery shopping at Meadowbank Aldi and Franklins etc. One of the great area i have lived.
For investment side, I have an IP in the newer side of the Meadowbank for around 3 years now. Pros: I have 0% vacancy rate since I bought it, rental rise approx. 5% yearly, no maintenance cost up to date (touch wood..).
Cons: I have only seen min. CG over the last 3 years, I guess around 10% gain to date. rental yield is not excited too, currently less than 6% gross.
Hope this help. By the way, i did considered Rhodes years ago, but the entry price is too expansive... for me.
cheers.