pennyk said:
But I do wonder whether it's overkill to have such a complex accounting program if you are just doing basic accounts? Is that what your accounting recommends. My accountant recommends a much more basic program for most people. I just can't think what it's called.
Penny
Hi Penny
Just to give you feedback about this question, my experience has been that I started off with developing my own [highlight]Access database[/highlight] to manage my accounts, then moved to using [highlight]Microsoft Money[/highlight], then moved to [highlight]Quicken[/highlight] and now in the last 6 months have moved to [highlight]MYOB[/highlight], so I have experience with using most of these packages.
My thoughts are that [highlight]MYOB[/highlight] is complicated but powerful if set up correctly. I would even go as far to say that basic knowledge of accounting is required in order to use which may be a deterrant for some people.
As Sim (who is the Somersoft [highlight]Quicken[/highlight] guru
) I would agree that it is easy to use and fairly intuitive. MYOB has a bit of an edge in terms of functionality but that is just my personal experience, and there is a trade off in less easy to use, & knowledge etc in using MYOB over Quicken.
[highlight]Money[/highlight] is pretty basic, and easy to use just without the grunt. It comes with a great cashflow analyser to predict the future balances of your accounts based on past spending behaviour.
Is the package you are thinking of [highlight]Cashbooks[/highlight] that your accountant recommends as a more basic program to use? My parents over the years have bought Quicken and MYOB to try and track there accounts, and ended up throwing them in the bin as they were to complicated for them to work out easily both from an upfront point of view and on-going. They are now happily set-up with Cashbooks and are using this relatively smoothly.
So for me, the test that I would apply is:
- How much do you know about accounting?
- How complex are your accountants?
If the answer to these questions is that you know a fair bit and have complex accounts, then go for [highlight]MYOB[/highlight].
If the answer to these questions is that you know very little and your accounts are simple, then go for [highlight]Cashbooks[/highlight]. [highlight]Quicken[/highlight] could probably be considered anywhere along this spectrum, it is a very good product.
All products in my experience require significant time and effort to set them up correctly, set up your chart of accounts, and reconciliation of account balances so they are all pretty much of a muchness (although MYOB is more complex to get going)
Just my thoughts though based on my experience using the products.
Good luck all
Cheers
Corsa