I have heard that people have been avoiding Chermside where paid parking came in late last year. Business slowed, at least from the stories I heard from stores in the centre. It was introduced about October/November and I suppose it was hoped that people would still shop there in the lead up to Christmas.
It is coming to Carindale next month. Staff parking at Chermside is $3 per day but I've heard that the staff carpark fills up early (no doubt plenty of staff didn't use the staff carpark before). If you miss out and have to park elsewhere, that will cost $20 for the day, apparently.
I've also heard the streets around Chermside are full of cars, and getting out through boomgates is a nightmare, and people are not happy to have their streets full of cars all day. I imagine it will be similar to real estate around Greenslopes Private Hospital where the parking issue considerably decreases the values and/or cuts the number of people prepared to buy there.
As there is a bus hub at Carindale (and most big shopping centres) the centre is trying to stop people parking there and catching the bus to town. All they have to do to stop that is to use a system where you validate a purchase (say $20) for free parking. If you are parked at a shopping centre all day, you must be spending $20. It would still entail boom gates and ticket machines and will slow things down so much, as has happened at Chermside.
I believe it is a mistake but until leases run out, shops must stay open, but if people avoid the centre and little shops close, perhaps the centres will only then start to lose money, and realise the folly of charging people to shop.
First three hours is free, but when I took my kids to Carindale when they were little, once you have lunch and/or see a movie, or do things to suit each child, three hours flies by.
Carindale is at the intersection of two major roads, so the available parking in nearby streets is pretty scarce. I would be pretty upset if I lived close enough to walk, because I would guess house values will drop due to having a street chock full of cars all day, every day.