The "You need it" argument is an emotional decision. There are many risks in life you can't insure against. You just need to accept that risk is part of life. No need to feed financial advisers & an insurance industry to reduce only a small part of your risks.
If you spend your life trying to analyze all your risks, you would suffer from analysis paralysis.
.
I am largely self insured on the income side too. Possibly for different reason though.
I can not agree in any way shape or form that such insurance is an emotional decision, and your view does need to be qualified in case someone takes it as "advice", as some no doubt will. Most cant make such a decision as you and I have made. They do NOT have the resources.
Stepping back, so you have a better understanding of my perspective, such business provides less than 3 % of our gross income at this time, so I couldnt give a hoot from that point of view.
When I sit with new investors, one of the things we cover off is what they believe their biggest risk might be.
Invariably, items such as "bad" tennants ( bad covers damage, non payers etc), interest rates, poor location, changes in planning rules, collapse of markets, legislative risk etc all come outout very easily.
Loss of income often needs to be coaxed out, and thats for any number of reasons, some of which are deep seated and quite logical fears
Take a youngish couple with kids, where the majority of income comes from PAYG and a bit of rent.............youd have to be a "brave" person to sit in front of them and suggest they self insure.
We always recommend a client retains cash or equity buffer, but thats geared more around being able to extend waiting periods so that premium costs can be reduced.
I am in the fortunate position to have seen what unexpected loss of income and unexpected early death can do to a family. The emotional side of things is bad enough, but to have these compounded by having to make 'LIFE" decisions based on poor risk planning results in additional immediate stress (which is avoidable) with potential effects beyind the current generation.
Although this type of decision looks simple, in practice it is not .
I will now hop off my soapbox.
ta
rolf