Tulamalula, thanks for starting an interesting discussion about pets in rental properties. It is great to hear that many people have good experience with pet owner tenants. I have recently launched a new web business addressing these same issues from both property investors and tenant points of view.
Yes I agree with the general consensus here that pet owners tend to be longer term and stable tenants, and a good relationship between landlord and tenant is very important.
How I feel about charging more rent for certain pet friendly properties is to cover extra maintenance costs, rather than taking advantage of pet lovers. More tenants (human or furry) = more wear and tear. Some properties do cost more to maintain, others cost the same so don't need to charge more. Tile or lino floors will cost less to maintain than carpet. Many tenants understand this and are willing to pay higher rent, according to this article $20 is quite reasonable.
http://www.firstnational.com.au/med...2012/February/Renting-With-Pets,-Think-Again…
I had a lawyer look into price differentials for with and without pets, and his recommendation was that it is legal because you are advertising two different products. Same logic as price differentials for furnished vs unfurnished, or charging more for air conditioning.
http://www.rentwithpets.com.au/index.php/landlords2/are-property-price-differentials-legal
DT, could you please send me a link to the part of act that specifically prohibits different prices for having pets. If that is the law I need to change the website to reflect this.
In terms of what pets are considered, I found that common real estate sites like domain, REA, gumtree don't address this well. For Rent With Pets, I've built checkboxes into the listing itself to help set guidelines on what pets are considered. eg. big dog, small dog, horse, guinea pig, outside animals, desexed, microchipped, wormed, vaccinated. These essentially help select for responsible people who are anal about looking after their pets and less likely to cause any trouble. You're welcome to list yours for free in exchange for some feedback as I'm still working on making it user friendly.
As a vet, I do see some cats that spray urine. This is quite easy to fix by desexing, and recommending that the tenants use feliway (pheromone that reduces stress that makes cats mark new territory). We have products like urine off that get rid of urine smells, and cleaning companies also carry better products that get rid of all traces of urine (more toxic ones).
The cats I live with love to scratch...but given the choice between scratching posts, fabric couch, doorframes and wooden floorboards they would rather go for my fabric couch! The key is for tenants to give them appealing scratching options so they don't scratch floors.
I would advertise your property as pet friendly, don't worry about the broken fence. I personally know of a few tenants that have offered to pay to fix fences if they want it to be secure for their dog. Win-win situation for both