17 year olds

I have only seen ten minutes of it, and thought it was gross. Apparently the second film is worse :eek: ... preferring for them to wait as long as possible to see such rubbish. ... There is enough time for him to see horrible, sleazy movies when he is a bit older. ... I'm curious to know of those who have seen Borat and Bruno, whether you think a 14 year old boy would enjoy them, or should be allowed to see them.
LMAO! I loved Borat and Bruno; Sacha Baron Cohen is one of the great comedians of the age.

I would think that Borat is quite tame for a 14-year-old. I can't imagine that anything in Borat would be a new concept for a 14-year-old, but perhaps I just can't remember the whole movie right now.

Bruno is more explicit and I'm not sure whether I'd allow them to watch that.
 
I'm curious to know of those who have seen Borat and Bruno, whether you think a 14 year old boy would enjoy them, or should be allowed to see them. When we first started discussing this yesterday, before the ruckus, my 18 year old son said the movie was pretty gross, his girlfriend said she was not interested in seeing Borat. She saw Bruno with my son and said he squirmed all through it.

It wasnt that bad a movie and apart from one particularly unsavoury scene that was more shocking then offensive. It was actually pretty funny in a very juvenile way. Kids are smarter then we give them credit for the reason its funny is because it is politically incorrect and they would understand this saying that though I wouldn't have let a 14 year old watch it, but if he has unsupervised access to the internet he has probnably seen much much worse.
 
Well handled WW.

There's some instant punishment as well as ongoing punishment that will keep him thinking about his actions.

Regards
Marty
 
Only time will tell Winston,i have seen some shocking things within the 'Private School Party Scene" over the years when picking up the daughters after parties,seems strange to me there was no skunk-nitro or other items young people poison themselves with these days did you ask that Question i know i would have,and it may shock you with what they say..willair..
 
I've seen Borat.

I think a 14y.o. would be laughing at all the rude jokes. Don't think it would scar him. I think the grossest part was when Borat & his rather obese male friend were wrestling nude (you see bottoms but not the front 'bits'). Other stupid bits are him having a wash in his hotel room using toilet water or doing a pooh in public.

From memory, it highlights how stupid, racist & sexist Americans are. I think you should watch it with your partner first as it is quite funny in parts.

It does run with jokes that become tired about a quarter of the way through the movie. But it also highlights portions of American society that are quite extreme eg the southerners, the gang boys, the newly graduated college boys on a road trip.
 
The inference that you will be bullied if you don't watch it is a concern. :(

Maybe there was an advantage in being brought up poor. Few could watch more than an occasional movie and "designer" stuff for kids? Forget it.

I was OK though. I had a rowing boat and went fishing. :D
 
I thought Borat was stupid! I watched it with my teens and would just drop in comments like "what a w**ker, "does he think that's funny" "gross". and then I shut up. They have never asked to see it again. I don't go on about it being to old for them or too rude, I just try to comment the way they do about my movies! lol. it did start some interesting discussions about southern racism and stereo-types in society.
 
I was OK though. I had a rowing boat and went fishing.

Fishing and boats kept me and my mates out of alot of trouble, too, Thommo.

We grew up near the water in Sydney and someone always had a tinny or a canoe or a little sailing boat we could use. Summer afternoons and weekends were spent in or on the water, and winter was spent fishing usually from shore. I reckon if we didn't have the Parramatta River to amuse us, we would have been real problem kids.
 
Thx for ongoing input everyone. It is reassuring to get others' views as it is tough to know what the new normal is, or should be.

Amadio, Joan, Player, OP, very good points made.

Sunfish, we've never had an issue like this before. I was pretty gob smacked that he'd be so stupid. He is an officer in cadets and won an award last year which involved a free trip to Germany for 2 weeks, where he hung out with cadets from Canada, Norway, Germany, and England doing 'cool stuff' like shooting German machine guns and pistols, driving tanks, and mountain biking with packs and rifles. Big school accolades for that when he got back, and given extra responsibility by the principal......obviously though, it has gone to his head a bit and he thinks he can control things and can't put a foot wrong. He also was selected for an advanced survival course in Tasmania last year. So we've thought his judgement and understanding of our authority was clear.

Willair, drugs were on my mind, and I was going to go through all the rubbish bags, but realized there mightn't be much evidence.

We try to emulate the best of how our parents brought us up, which is reasonably strict and black and white, but it seems many other parents, hence their kids, are more lax and compromising.....as if everything is negotiable if the kids can make a well reasoned case. It's like there's a more diverse range of values out there these days then when I was at school. I appreciate that makes it harder for kids to determine what is normal.

One of the things that concerns me is the amount of money so many kids are given, and their lack of respect for property and possessions. Some kids in the 17yo's grade have their own cars worth over 40k and don't particularly treat them well. I knew kids like that when at school, and I thought it was p;ss poor.

Re the sex talk, being in the health field, I've covered that as best I can....shown them lots of big glossy full color close up pics of venereal diseases and the many varieties of herpes simplex, and how they can be related to ongoing cognitive, neural, and immune dysfunction, and several varieties of cancer. Basically, paint genitals and throats as a bacterial cesspit, and drive home why it is better to have fewer sex partners. I think both boys get that.

We've also focused on how important it is not to take advantage of girls, how some know no better than to throw their bodies around to get attention and acceptance from boys.....when the noble thing to do is lift them up and feed their self esteem, not slide down into that bad space they are in..... Also how important one's reputation is. The girls you might treat badly will still be around in 5,10,20 years time, maybe in the same suburb, working in the same company, kids at the same schools, and what goes around comes around.

also talked about techniques for sublimating male sex drive....more physical activity, focus on academic achievement, part time job, time limits on dirty joke sessions, focus on girl's personalities and character first, faces second, brains third, bodies fourth....engage their brains, talk to them about politics and how to make the world a better place, their dreams and ambitions, all this in addition to goofing off.

My focus over the next week is going to be how to bring out the best in himself and his mates, and steer them away from extreme behavior, before it happens....recognize the mood and read the situation that precedes these things.

To me it seems kids don't intend for things to escalate, but they've got so much energy and pack mentality, and so little capacity to draw a line in the sand, that things take on a momentum that is quickly lost control of. The lowest common denominator or most outrageous person, spirals the situation down, and the rest laugh and reinforce it.

Anyway, must get my head into other things. What I resent about these incidents is the amount of energy and time they occupy one's head and belly. Hard to focus on anything else for days.
 
can i adopt you as a secondary parent to my kid. wow.

personally i was a "better to beg forgiveness than ask permission" gal, so not a really good role model ... but i will never forget the look of disappointment in my mum's eyes if i was caught doing something wrong (not that i did bad stuff often, just often enough).

p.s. i thought borat was disgusting and not funny in the slightest
 
also talked about techniques for sublimating male sex drive....more physical activity, focus on academic achievement, part time job, time limits on dirty joke sessions, focus on girl's personalities and character first, faces second, brains third, bodies fourth....engage their brains

The tough part about this is the easy access to porn for kids now. When we were young, it was magazines only. They weren't all that hard to get, but looking back they were pretty tame.
 
Willair, drugs were on my mind, and I was going to go through all the rubbish bags, but realized there mightn't be much evidence.
.
I knew you would has covered that base Winston,because within the Social Hierarchy within the Private School System there would be pressure to try different items,as my daughters told me many times several in their school over the years were stoned 24-7 and their Teachers knew nothing,but that all comes back to the parents and what the young people see as normal,a simple blood test tells all:)..
Your Son is a very lucky Young Man,Winston all my father ever taught me was buy it for 20 cents and sell it for 5 bucks,and bring your family up to trust in God..willair..
 
To me it seems kids don't intend for things to escalate, but they've got so much energy and pack mentality, and so little capacity to draw a line in the sand, that things take on a momentum that is quickly lost control of.

I remember as a teenager that when I did something wrong, Mum would yell, Dad would speak quietly (which was much more frightening, I can assure you) and punishment/s handed down.

Often, though, more rope would be given in future. This gave me a chance to prove and redeem myself, show what I'd learn from last time, and display some leadership and initiative in keeping the scenario under control and resulting in a different outcome.

So I wonder, if he's showing genuine remorse - for the act, not the punishment - then perhaps it might be worth considering the provision of more rope? Certainly, there is a risk that his decision-making won't improve, and that ensuing events may turn out worse... but, showing faith in him to do the right things may work out well for everyone.

Just a thought, if it helps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: weg
.. but, showing faith in him to do the right things may work out well for everyone.

I believe in punishing immediately, and in right portion, then getting on with the business of life with no lingering undercurrents. He needs to understand he did wrong, and has been punished. But he also needs to get back to the job of evolving into an adult. When I think of the young adults that were here getting smashed, I wonder at how none of them probably had responsibilities or hopes and aspirations to follow up on the next day. Too much dead time and too much of Mum and Dad's money.

I will probably set more tasks for him to occupy his head and expand his outlook. He has a mate simultaneously doing a carpentry apprenticeship and yr12. I had it in mind for them to do minor renovation work of the latest IP. He is over prepping and painting there at the moment, with Mum.

I'd like both boys to get used to talking to council and town planners and engineers, and spending more time in the adult world. Let them model themselves on adults, not their peers. I think peer pressure is stronger when a kid doesn't spend enough time with adults, learning to model themselves on adults getting about adult business.

So yes, we will be setting tasks and giving more rope. But not in relation to free reign of the house.

We had the 19yo at a Reno Kings workshop a few weekends ago. It made a big impact. He was the youngest person by far, and there was a lot of highly motivated life experience in the room. Many attendees spent a lot of time encouraging him. Without exception, they all said they wished they'd started when they were his age. Incidentally, the Reno Kings let him in for a heavily discounted rate, after I asked for it. I thought that was really big of them. BTW, it was very good value for money in my opinion.
 
When I think of the young adults that were here getting smashed, I wonder at how none of them probably had responsibilities or hopes and aspirations to follow up on the next day. Too much dead time and too much of Mum and Dad's money.
I dunno; think they'll make time for things they prioritise anyway. :D When I was in 3rd year at uni I took 17 (yes, SEVENTEEN) subjects - each with an exam :eek: - yet I still went out on Friday night and had *ahem* a few beverages, and more than once caught a taxi straight to my Saturday morning job at 8am. :eek: Then I'd work until 1pm, go home and crash for a couple of hours, then get up and do a few hours' study before heading out to repeat the whole thing Saturday night. Ah, those were the days... now that all sounds terribly tiring, and I'd rather stay home with a DVD and be asleep by 10:30pm. :p

In all seriousness, it sounds like they're young men to be proud of, and hopefully will get through the perils of young adulthood with just embarrassing stories to recall, and no tragedies.
 
I dunno; think they'll make time for things they prioritise anyway. :D When I was in 3rd year at uni I took 17 (yes, SEVENTEEN) subjects - each with an exam :eek: - yet I still went out on Friday night and had *ahem* a few beverages, and more than once caught a taxi straight to my Saturday morning job at 8am. :eek: Then I'd work until 1pm, go home and crash for a couple of hours, then get up and do a few hours' study before heading out to repeat the whole thing Saturday night. Ah, those were the days... now that all sounds terribly tiring, and I'd rather stay home with a DVD and be asleep by 10:30pm. :p

In all seriousness, it sounds like they're young men to be proud of, and hopefully will get through the perils of young adulthood with just embarrassing stories to recall, and no tragedies.

Agree with this. At 17 most will have tried alcohol, and many will be drinking regularly. This doesn't mean they'll end up in moral decline or on drugs.

I'd concentrate now on teaching and reminding him to keep safe.

Ozperp, I bet even though you partied hard you knew your boundries and didn't overstep the line.

This lad is 17, is leading a busy productive life and has done all the right things, and done them well, up to this point.

He's misjudged badly as a one off, but hopefully he learns from this.

If it were me I'd make sure he gets full credit for his successes and although I'm sure you'd handle this well WW, I hope this doesn't impact negatively on your relationship or his studies in the following months.
 
DH and I were both Army Cadets (NCO's), it was how we met and got together. The amount of drugs, sex and alcohol going on at cadets is no different to the amount you will find at any school or other activity where teenagers congregate and meet up.

I think that any parent who thinks 'my kid doesn't drink, etc' is delusional. My parents had no idea of the half of what I was up to as a teenager, and I was a reasonably sensible teenager. Usually when they were worried I was up to anything, there was nothing going on. But the other 90% of the time when they thought I was completely innocent, well lets just say I wasn't...

I scored top grades acedemically, My teachers all loved me, was on the student council and the debating team, tutored other kids, was friends with everyone. Was basically a model teenager. Word of warning, it's the kids like me you need to watch out for, because you really have no idea of what I might actually be up too. My parents still don't believe I drink - Yet I have had alcohol poisioning more times then I care to remember as a teenager and uni student. Luckily, I grew up.

Anyway, I do know that amongst my main group of friends in high school; not one of us was still a virgin by the end of year 12, all of us drank, most had at least tried grass or some other elicit substance. Making stupid mistakes is a part of being a teenager, as is not thinking about the consequences, or thinking they only apply to someone else.

Just some food for thought.
 
Back
Top