Berwick compared to frankston- no brainer. Berwicks an ugly outer suburb with a 2 hour commute if you miss the train, frankston has its ugly parts but has the bay and upside and Oliver's hill precinct which berwick has no comparison.
Berwick not so much
Berwick is marginally nicer than even Frankston South and has a superior rail line in every way (closer, express, 2 fully functional stations etc). Frankston in comparison to Berwick is effectively Dandenong on the beach (and Frankstons rep arguably worse than that of Dandenong/Doveton).
Olivers Hill has some nice views/blocks but the quality of the beach itself is heavily overrated (I'd prefer any beachside suburb along the Great Ocean Rd
), however let's not forget Olivers Hill is an island in a sea of Dandenong! Even most of Olivers Hill itself is old and rundown with cheap floating low socioeconomic beach style homes, the area is not as well well maintained by the council. The houses, blocks, streets, public gardens, infrastructure etc all radiate that off putting low socio-econmic 70's look, that reminds you that you still live in Frankston no matter what area it is, dangerous cracks in the paving, roads patched with rubber etc. If they ripped up all the homes on Olivers hill, laid new roads, paving, nice commercial districts ie effectively started over it could be nicer than Berwick due to the rare views but the fact is the town was obviously built on a budget in comparison to other suburbs at the time
There's no comparison for Berwick in Frankston, and I know where I'd much rather live if we're talking rich. Not one single street in Olivers Hill looks as nice as any of the richest streets in Berwick! You feel Dandenong in Olivers Hill the moment you leave your driveway, or begin your walk to the beach.. and not even building a 4 million dollar home will change that street demographic until the streets/nature strips/gardens are actually maintained/redone by a proper council!
http://www.realestate.com.au/property-house-vic-berwick-118354347
Yes wouldn't look bad with a beach but it's preference
I still prefer it to Olivers as I can't see a hundred aged/cracked Terracotta rooftops plaguing the view constantly reminding me my Olivers home is a million dollar view of centrelink rooftops every time I try to enjoy it
Frankston is a funny area, very mixed demographics! However it appears richer people moving in ie building nicer homes in an unchanged town. Are the streets, shops, being made nicer along with it? In comparison Berwick is bombarded with upgrades such as Bryn Mawr Bridge, Casey Hospital, Clyde rd upgrade, Nossal, and trainline/station. Frankston looks no different than 20yrs ago and those roads/parks could really use a cosmetic upgrade!